Persecution of the Feminine: Remembering Jenny Horne
|
Getting your Trinity Audio player ready...
|
Estimated reading time: 17 minutes
The persecution of the feminine is a blood red, often silent, shamed and ungrieved wound that runs through our collective memories. And it affects all of us, regardless of gender.
Last year a topic that I had touched on briefly in a constellation context several years ago, really grabbed hold of my heart. It was the persecution of witches, more specifically the persecution of witches in Scotland.
The persecution of witches encapsulates the persecution of women and the feminine – the cost of being different, too loud, too quiet, too pretty, too bold, too free. ‘Witch’ became, and still is, a pejorative word. A woman in power who speaks outside of the system she is part of, is often referred to as a ‘witch’ to silence or marginalise her voice.
The persecution of the feminine isn’t limited to witch persecutions. It also isn’t relegated to the dim and distant past.
The topic came to my attention again because of a study undertaken by the University of Edinburgh. They have introduced a research project dedicated to exploring and documenting the persecution of witches in Scotland and the unknown narrative that surrounds it.
I only happened upon it when they published an interactive online map(1) where you can search for what is known of the stories of these men, women and children. When I went online to have a look I realised the shocking scale of the persecution that took place in Scotland.
When I think about the persecution of witches, the places that come to mind are Salem in Massachusetts or perhaps the European witch trials in Spain or Germany. I knew that it had happened in Scotland too, but I really had no concept of the scale.
Approximately 4000 people were accused of witchcraft in Scotland between the 16th and 18th century. The persecution in Scotland was five times higher than anywhere else in Europe. The land in Scotland, where I live, holds the imprint of the accusations, betrayals, persecutions, deaths, and fears of this period of history.
The past lives inside us – that of our ancestors and predecessors and the choices they made – flow through our blood. Their stories may be imprinted on our souls in such a way that we are unconsciously following in their footsteps.
In Scotland of the estimated 4000 known trials that took place, Edinburgh University have estimated that approximately 84% of them were women, and an estimated 65% of those accused were killed. In Salem there were 200 trials: 30 people were found guilty and 19 people were hanged.
The numbers in Scotland are startlingly high in comparison. For most the details are sparse: name; place of trial; accuser and accusations; method of death etc.
Patterns appear in the research – clusters of women accusing other women after they themselves had been accused. Regardless of the cause of the accusation, once someone was accused they would be interrogated. This included sleep deprivation, starvation and torture methods like the burning of feet, until they gave in and accused other women, and the cycle continued.
The political structure of the time and the beliefs of King James (I &VI) certainly fuelled those high numbers in Scotland. I was compelled to look beyond that to try to uncover some of those silenced voices of those souls who were accused, taken from their families and homes, and in so many cases executed.
Listening to the voiceless
There were differences in the root causes of the accusations in that time period. The general collective beliefs encompassing spiritual and religious practices in those times were different from the general collective beliefs held today. It was normal to seek help from a healer for ill health, bad luck, poor crops and everything in between. Some individuals who were accused of witchcraft had notes in the court record such as:
- Herbs/Spells
- Observations of moon
- Familiar (e.g. hare or cat)
This was the narrative of the first story that we chose of Jean Thomson from Kircudbright, who was executed in 1659.
However, so many others were accused of witchcraft in order to control and modify their behaviour to force them to fit within the accepted norms of the time. This could be because of a dispute with a neighbour, a real or imagined slight or, in many cases, simply for being different. A woman who owned her own land; a widow who had no one to speak for her; someone who looked different, who dared to live differently or for whatever reason was perceived as ‘other’. This was the fate of the woman we chose for our second story – Jenny Horne from Dornoch.
Jean Thomson
The themes that emerged in the first constellation of Jean Thomson were deeply moving and significant, but there was something else present within the Jenny Horne story.
With Jean, patterns around the separation of mothers and children were very prominent. The shame and grief of the husbands and fathers, their impotence in the face of the Church and the ‘witch finder’, the machine that was supported by the system of governance that was set in motion following any accusation.
Jean Thomson pleaded not guilty. The provost of Kirkcudbright testified in her case. She had been previously censured by the Kirk. She was accused by Janet Miller – a confessing ‘witch’ who had denounced her.
The most striking parts within the unfolding constellation were the inheritance of the trauma and the impact on the descendants in the present. We witnessed in the descendants a need to keep running and to stay silent in order to be safe. For those descendants linked to the accusers, we saw the need to uphold persecution as a tool to enable them to be safe in the present. This is a recurring wound that we are seeing in so many of our collective memories and I am seeing it appear time and again in individual sessions.
The entanglements within the constellation could not be released until the original accuser could look at the root of her own guilt. And it wasn’t the guilt of accusing another mother or woman in her hometown of being a witch, it was the guilt of not being able to keep her own child safe. It was the belief that if she accused someone else, then her daughter would be released and allowed to live. That unfortunately wasn’t the case, for her or for the many others. This is a lived wound that is carried by us, the present descendants, and it is woven through our everyday lives.
The power of witnessing in a constellation is huge
It is ‘seeing’ an entanglement that begins the process of disentangling. There are times in the constellation setting where you step into the stories that are known and familiar. They may not have been seen by the individuals in question, but they have been seen; they are known on some level of consciousness. And then there are times when you set up the created Constellation Field and step into the known parts in order to discern the unknown and the missing, and it feels different. It feels different because it hasn’t been seen. There is the sense that whoever is looking is the first in their lineage or family Field to actively choose to see, to actively choose to bear witness to what happened. The constellation for Jenny Horne was one such constellation.
Jenny Horne
In preparing for the day we discovered that ‘Jenny Horne’ probably wasn’t even the real name of the woman in question. It had become common practice, particularly in the north of Scotland, to refer to any woman accused of witchcraft as ‘Jenny Horne’. Their names were taken from them too.
Jenny and her daughter were arrested in Dornoch in Sutherland in 1727 and imprisoned on the accusations of her neighbours. Jenny Horne was showing signs of senility, and her daughter had a deformity of her hand. The neighbours accused Jenny of ‘having used her daughter as a pony to ride to the Devil, where she had her shod by him’. The trial was conducted very quickly; the sheriff had judged both guilty and sentenced them to be burned at the stake. Unusually for the time she was burned alive. There are records of her last words as she was led to her death as being: “What a bonny blaze!” It is likely that Jenny Horne was suffering from dementia and it was this that led to her accusation. She didn’t understand what was happening to her.
Her daughter managed to escape, but Jenny was stripped, smeared with tar, feathered, and paraded through the town in a barrel and burned alive. Nine years after her death the witchcraft acts were repealed in Scotland.
The represented spaces included within the constellation were:
- Jenny Horne
- Jenny’s daughter
- Accusers
- Witchfinder
- Church
- Beliefs
- Silence
- Persecution
- Belonging
- Innocence
- Current Descendants of victims
- Current Descendants of accusers
- Current Descendants of witchfinders
- Betrayal
- Fire
It was a very emotional constellation to witness. The threads that had been present in the previous story were very much evident again:
- The fracturing between mothers and children.
- The need to run in order to be safe.
- The need to separate and be alone in order to be safe.
- The need to be silent in order to be safe.
- The fracture between the descendants and the ancestors.
These threads were passed from one generation to the next for centuries. The representative for the ‘Church’ was initially firm in their belief that what was happening, and had happened, was the right thing. They were refusing to acknowledge the other representatives within the created constellation Field, aside from the ‘witchfinder’ representative.
However, as the constellation unfolded, the ‘Church’ distanced itself from the ‘witchfinder’. At one point the ‘Church’ said: “No, this is not in my name.” as the ‘witchfinder’ became more and more animated with persecution. This is perhaps an indication of the beginnings of a move away from the sanctioned witch trials.
There was constant movement and chaos indicating the layer upon layer of unacknowledged inherited guilt and unexpressed grief. It isn’t surprising, particularly in the Jenny Horne constellation, as we were already looking at 164 years of legalised persecution at that point. There would already be transgenerational inheritance of the trauma of persecution. Generation after generation had experienced directly or inherited the need to run, to escape, to be silent, and to become an unseen woman. And that inheritance has carried on down the lines to us – the current descendants of those women.
What was interesting was how strong this response was within the descendants represented in the group, combined with a resistance or fear of actually ‘seeing’ the victims, trapping the descendants in the entangled trauma of their ancestors’ past.
There was an immediate sense of tension and fear within the created constellation space. The confusion and terror were palpable within the Jenny Horne representative. I added further representatives for other women who had also been tried under the name of Jenny Horne. This eased the terror somewhat for the original representative, but each of the ‘Jenny Horne’ women were attempting to hide, to seek safety, and to remain unseen within the created constellation space.
We are here because they were here
The turning points within the unfolding constellation came with the inclusion of the current descendants, not just of these ‘witches’, but of all representations:
- Those who had accused
- Witchfinders
- The accused
- Persecuted and executed
- Those who had escaped
The ‘witchfinder’ was fuelled by the unrest among the current descendants – not one of them could or would acknowledge any of the ‘Jenny Horne’ representatives or the ‘dead’ within the Field.
There was significant resistance with the descendants of the ‘accusers’ and ‘witchfinders’ in particular. They were not ‘seeing’ the dead or the victims. Instead they vacillated between the ‘witchfinder’ and the descendants of the persecuted and exclaimed: “I didn’t do this. This wasn’t me. Please forgive me.”
They were asking the descendants, and eventually directly asking the dead along with the ‘Jenny Horne’ representatives, to hold their guilt. They still weren’t connecting with the dead or the victims; there was no compassion or grief. They were instead attempting to absolve their own guilt rather than ‘see’ and witness the trauma. This in itself is another form of persecution, and further entangles the victims. It is the heavy inherited knowing of the price we pay for survival in such circumstances.
I have observed this response in other collective, focused constellations I have facilitated involving the theme of persecution, such as: the historical cost of belonging for those who were enslaved and enslavers, Native American massacres, or the Magdalene Laundries.
The wound of the unexpressed grief is carried by the descendants, and unexpressed grief is not benign. The weight of the guilt and the pain, the trauma itself, is so great that a belief exists that to even allow themselves to ‘see’ it is dangerous, and a collective ‘agreement’ is made to not acknowledge the cost of survival or to ‘see’ those that did not survive. Instead the current descendants can often be drawn to attempting to absolve themselves from guilt. They ask the victims and descendants of the victims to hold the pain instead of seeing and witnessing what happened themselves.
A huge painful wound exists throughout this entangled Field and the current descendants behave as if they are ancestors, and of that time, rather than living in the present moment. The ancestors’ stories are held as tightly as if they were their own stories.
The sense of safety is unconsciously derived from walking in the footsteps of the ancestors, in living their fear, their pain, their rage, their grief, and their need to keep running in order to be safe or to have a place. Or in the case of the descendant of the accuser and witch hunter, it comes from the need to continue to persecute or accuse in order to have a place and to belong, along with denying the story of those that suffered.
The cost of compassion
This is an all too common response in victim and perpetrator patterns generally. It is easier to focus on the perpetration and on the fight; it takes courage and compassion to sit with and actually see the victims, to sit with and bear witness to the souls who have suffered, to hear their untold stories. This is what moves the entrenched entanglements. It is significantly harder within the collective context, because of these collective agreements to not see. We become vulnerable to the fear that we too will be outcast if we dare to see or dare to grieve.
It was only after the descendants in the present slowly began to ‘see’ the dead, the persecuted, the victims, that the entangled Field gradually began to move. Only when they looked outside of their need to blame the ‘Church’ and the ‘witchfinder’, when they stepped outside of the need to perpetrate on the perpetrators, that the Field moved. I included a separate representative for the descendants of ‘those who chose not to see’– the silent witnesses of the original trauma, in an effort to further move the entanglement.
For a significant period there was a ‘stand-off’ between this representative, the witchfinder and the Church. The descendant of ‘those who chose not to see’ was aggressively engaged with the witchfinder, angry at what had happened and yet they too still chose not to see the dead or the victims.
Their anger was related to how difficult it was for them to be descendants of such perpetration – there was no compassion whatsoever for the victims. This is also an entanglement that I have witnessed in several other collective constellations and has its roots in a particular inherited triangulation pattern connected to the cost of belonging. The triangulation is a formation of aspects from the core elements of ‘Those who left’, ‘Those left behind’ and ‘Descendants in the present’. When the deep wound relating to the cost of surviving remains ungrieved and unacknowledged, the stories of the souls within it become silenced. Stories become silent when they are painful and hard to sit with; when they involve guilt and shame; when the survival has come at the cost of others. For safety, parts of the story can be glossed over, and when these stories are big stories – collective stories that are passed down generationally in our cultures – then entire sections of the society within that culture become unseen and voiceless. The holders and listeners that subscribe to the single story don’t see or hear their stories because, for them, the safety comes from the single story.
It is easy to look to the fight, the violence or to the beliefs held as justification; it is hard to see the vulnerable, the victims, the innocence lost – those souls become unseen and the patterns perpetuate. Not only that, an invisible hierarchy is created of who is worthy of grief and who isn’t.
Throughout this stand-off the dead had been calling out:
“I died. Please see me.
I died. Please see me.”
It was grief that needed to be expressed.
There was no response from any of the representatives in the stand-off. Each of the Jenny Horne representatives was trapped in their need to hide and escape; they too could not see the dead. They remained the unmourned dead.
This entanglement highlights the inheritance of the shame of persecution, the belief that the persecuted and executed need to stay separate to keeps the ‘others’ safe. This then creates a severing of the bond between loved ones, mothers and children, the seen and the unseen, those perceived as worthy of being mourned for and those not.
This particular entanglement highlights the cruelty of the trauma in the moment, but also the devastation for the descendants whose emotional relationships are tarnished by this need to be unseen, silent, running and alone in order to be safe. For if there is no place for grief then there is no real place for love. The place that exists will be diminished and stilted.
The myth of the ‘good girl’
The pressure to be the ‘good girl’, the ‘good daughter’, the ‘good wife and mother’ comes from this place and this entanglement. It is an invisible inheritance and it is not a helpful one. It can show itself when a woman wants to end a relationship, to work during motherhood, to be alone, to be seen or heard; or to hold a belief outside of the system of belonging in which she finds herself.
When I gently guided those descendants to sit with the dead, the created Constellation Field stilled. The silence was heavy, but finally those descendants were able to sit with the dead.
From their heart they were able to say: “I see you.” They didn’t ask for their ancestors’ guilt to be absolved or excused, they simply said: “I see you.” The unseen were seen. The silence began to break – little waves of movement rippled through the Field.
The original Jenny Horne from this story looked to her own daughter who had escaped. Her daughter finally met her eyes. She had been running and hiding throughout the constellation. Several of the women who were representing Jenny Horne moved around them and the silence broke.
The descendants of those who were executed were able to say to the dead and the victims:
“I have been holding your unlived years.”
“I feel the desecration here.”
“I am claiming back the sacred.”
Jenny Horne screamed. An un-screamed scream was heard. Everything within the constellation stopped to witness. There was more than one voice held within that scream. The silence of countless women was broken too. I stopped the constellation shortly after to allow for the movements to settle within the Field and the representatives.
Claiming a place as a free woman
Collective constellations are somewhat different to individual, focused constellations.
As is so often the way with a collective memory or story, care has to be taken with the Constellation Field to bring each of the representatives back into their own individual fields of influence. I decided to do this by way of an individual exercise within the group setting.
Usually I work with dyads or triads to drop back down into the individual spaces. But this time I asked each person present to breathe into their own place, their land, their name. And when they were ready, I invited them to step forward into the working constellation space, to slowly and gently walk through the Field space and say to each individual they encountered: “I am not Jenny Horne, I am (their name).” I suggested they maintain eye contact if they could and listen as the other person spoke the words to them.
It was a powerful way to honour the individuals present, the persecuted individuals in the story, their collective and ancestral connection to that, as well as Jenny Horne herself.
This was the last in-person workshop that I facilitated in 2020 before the world changed with the pandemic and lockdown. It was somewhat surreal to go from such a powerfully intense group experience to another shared collective experience of a pandemic.
The ripples in the Field are still unfolding for many who were present. Jenny Horne has stayed in our hearts and memories. I have noticed the threads revealed in the workshop, and other collective themed constellations, show up in the individual sessions that I am facilitating throughout this time.
Inherited collective memories of trauma relating to persecution, famine, and migration are reanimating as we move through this present day collective trauma. I’m noticing where we are individually and collectively choosing to see or not see the victims of this pandemic in the present. Now still, it is all too easy to go into the distraction of the ‘fight’ rather than sit with and see the vulnerable and those that suffer.
‘Jenny Horne’ as a collective dislocated memory has been very present in some of these sessions, the representation of a woman accused, tortured and executed for being ‘other’ – losing her name, her place, her safety, her life.
I am choosing to remember her and all of those displaced souls that are in resonance with her story. I invite you to do the same.
If they are worthy of grief, then so too are you.
It they were worthy of belonging, then so are you.
If they are worthy of being seen, you are worthy of being seen, and the forgotten living are also worthy of being seen.
It is difficult to lean into stories of persecution of the feminine. The weight of the unexpressed grief is all-consuming. But the act of witnessing those souls, even if it doesn’t seem to move or release in the moment, the act of sitting with the souls and whispering to them: “You are worthy of remembrance. You are worthy of my tears. You are worthy of my mourning. You are worthy of grief,” makes a difference. It creates a place for grief and it tends the wound.
NOTES:
These observations are taken from different group sessions. The Jenny Horne observations are from a group facilitated alongside Oona McFarlane, a wonderful Firewalk facilitator and therapist (www.celticfire.co.uk). The Firewalk ceremony was a powerful way in which to support the representatives in the group to honour the stories of the past whilst reclaiming their own voices and stories.
To date, there has been no apology, no pardon and no memorial to those who lost their lives in Scotland. There is now a campaign to grant an apology to those souls who were persecuted for witchcraft in Scotland.
REFERENCES
Fierke, K., & Mackay, N. (2020) To ‘see’ is to break an entanglement: Quantum Measurement, Trauma and Security. Security Dialogue. Ottawa, Canada.
Goodare, J. (2002) The Scottish Witch-Hunt in Context. Manchester University Press, England, UK.
Jackson, L. (1995) Witches, wives and mothers: witchcraft persecution and women’s confessions in seventeenth-century England, Women’s History Review, 4:1, 63-84. England, UK.
Mackay, N. (2020) Your Invisible Inheritance. Rebel Magic Books. England, UK.
Rosen, M. (2017) A Feminist Perspective on the History of Women as Witches. Dissenting Voices, 6:1. New York, USA.