Voiceless Women – An Unspoken Legacy
|
Getting your Trinity Audio player ready...
|
Estimated Reading Time: 19 minutes
Women’s stories and contributions are often unacknowledged, unseen, and silenced. The missing voices and stories become an all too familiar part of the everyday landscape, passing quietly from one generation to the next. In the familiarity of this silent landscape, the missing pieces can go unnoticed and unquestioned. That doesn’t mean that those pieces don’t exist or are benign.
Those women who came before in the family and ancestral field have shaped those that come after. Those that were the first in the lineage to do or experience certain things, willingly or unwillingly, have left a particular imprint. The first to marry for love, to divorce, the first to choose to study and have a career, when that simply wasn’t what was done. The first to travel, to follow a different belief, the first to vote, to own land and property in their own name – they will all be there in the family and ancestral field. The brave and courageous women who carved their own paths and went their own way, despite perhaps tremendous pressure and a great cost to do otherwise. Those are exciting, inspiring, and exhilarating stories that often remain untold or are reduced to a short couple of sentences about what a ‘pistol’ a particular ancestor was, or how stubborn and difficult she had been.
What of the other women? Those who were rendered voiceless within their own lifetimes, who found themselves married off without any attention paid to whether it was their heart’s desire or not. Or those who were relegated to ‘spinsterhood’ by the cultural conditioning. The women whose dreams of learning, creating, travelling, working, were quashed by the weight of expectations of being the ‘good daughter’, the ‘good sister’, the ‘good wife’, the ‘good mother’.
Women trapped in abusive situations, women who lost their homes, their dreams, their safety, and their ability to say ‘No’. Those who did their best to survive it, even if that meant hardening their hearts and trying not to feel. That takes courage too, but those stories are even more silenced, unlikely to be mentioned at family gatherings or in any other place. The women who grew brittle and bitter as life and the times they lived in rendered them ghosts whilst they were still alive. The reluctant brides, the widows, the ‘old maids’, the would-be authors, the would-be travellers, doctors, farmers. The weight of crushing disappointment and oppressive ‘choices’, the cost of conforming and the cost of not.
The freedom to choose is far greater today than it was then. And yet the lens of the oppressiveness of that old world is still one that individuals can each see or be seen through today.
This vast spectrum of voiceless female experience informs the descendants in the present in many different ways. Although we do not yet live in a world where all is equal for all genders in all places, it is significantly better today than it was for our ancestors. The freedom to choose is far greater today than it was then. And yet the lens of the oppressiveness of that old world is still one that individuals can each see or be seen through today.
When I work with individuals or groups to explore the stories of the women in their family and ancestral field, there can be a romanticised notion of what the experience will be like. Of perhaps uncovering a lesser-known branch of their family tree where there will be a sense of kindredness and ‘coming home’, a resonance of spirit and soul.
Of course, that does actually happen, but the journey from here to there involves sitting with the stories and people that are known as well as those that are unknown. The legacy of these voiceless women has been permeating through lineages for generation upon generation. Some of those souls are wounded, scarred, prickly, and often haunted by their own ghosts. The legacy of such wounded ghosts is the creation of more wounded and scarred souls.
The legacy of these voiceless women has been permeating through lineages for generation upon generation.
The wounded people in the family field have been entangled with the costs of the previous generations being rendered voiceless and unseen. The pain is real and it is lived generationally. This means that the first brush with the voiceless legacy of the unseen women in an individual’s lineage and field most likely will be through the painful relationships in the generations that are closest to them, because we are each still living the unacknowledged trauma of these women and it is no small wound.
The mother, grandmother, great aunts, who were bitter, who withheld their love and spread numbness or pain, is as much a legacy of the voicelessness placed on the women in the influent field as the unknown heroine who struck out on her own, defying all odds. The quiet gentle great-grandmother who was encumbered with an alcoholic partner, and ‘made do and mended’ in poverty for her entire lifetime is as much a legacy as the woman who fought the system to go to university and became a doctor. Both paths require immense fortitude, sacrifice, and grace.
We can be as bound to seeing our ancestors through the ‘good girl’ lens as we are impacted by it ourselves – consciously or unconsciously drawn to the ‘good ancestors’, the ‘good women’ rather than the bitter, cold, wounded souls. It is hard to sit with someone else’s pain, particularly when it has been unmet by them or those around them, when it has morphed into bitterness, sometimes vindictiveness, and downright nastiness. Behind that unmet pain is unmet and ungrieved grief, and behind that is a story yet to be told – not an excuse but a story.
The Making of Scarlet Women
A tool for control in any system is shame and blame. The cost of stepping outside of the cultural rules in the community or family we live in is high. This legacy of shame and blame runs through every family and ancestral system. Even that choice to explore, to see what is there, can be a provocative one and go against the beliefs and agreements that run through the structure of a family system.
Those designated as ‘Scarlet women’ are women who act or speak outside of the system that they live in, whether that is family or cultural. The scarlet women entanglement comes in as the cost of not being the ‘good girl’. In the past, ‘Scarlet women’ were defined as sinful, promiscuous, or immoral. Things that happen today that are commonplace, such as divorce, having a baby when unmarried, abortion, speaking out against injustice and violence, saying no to things, saying yes to things, choosing a certain type of career, would have resulted in huge consequences for the ancestors. It would also bring in the legacy of the ‘scarlet woman entanglement’.
Mistakes are Sacred too
In many of the collective memory constellations involving this and other associated ‘good girl’ dynamics, voicelessness and the fear of breaking a silence plays a key role. This is the fear of the cost of being true to oneself. The great fear of being different, of being seen to be different. Where courage has been grasped to dare to be different, in whatever form that courageous choice takes, for the ancestors and the descendants, there is fear of what might happen next. Not only in the perceived cost of making the choice itself, and that if an individual dares to choose themselves they may find themselves rootless and cast out.
No, the fear is much more than that. The fear comes in around a belief that they need to be perfect and get it right. Now that they have dared to be free, somehow they need to be more perfect than if they had stayed and conformed, submitted, capitulated to the ‘good girl’. The deep need to be perfect stems from a damaging inherited belief that safety is only to be found in ‘perfect’. This shows up in so many ways and it is a trap because perfect isn’t real. It is impossible. It is a prison where all those souls who dared to dream outside of the ‘good girl’ entanglement are in grave danger of ending up. In the stories I have stepped into with groups exploring this dynamic there are interesting words spoken from this entanglement. And they are repeated, in different stories, with different groups of people. When this repetition of a spoken entanglement happens, it points to a root pattern. The words spoken have been:
“I made a mistake. I got it wrong. Please don’t kill me.”
And the fear for those speaking is always palpable. Mistakes are believed to be a death sentence, because for some ancestors they were. The roots of this belief are full of shame, shunning, exclusion and perpetration. But who among us has lived a perfect life? I know I haven’t. I don’t think I have ever met anyone who has. It is not possible. However, the need to be ‘perfect’ if we dare to be seen and heard, or ‘good’ and submit to the agreements placed upon the ancestors, has become a lived legacy.
Mistakes are believed to be a death sentence, because for some ancestors they were.
It also creates patterns whereby the women in the ancestral field have persecuted each other within the system of beliefs they live in. When I work with these stories there is of course the presence of the patriarchal system and cultural system, but there is also the need to survive at whatever cost that runs like a deep undercurrent through the stories. Women against women, entangled within the system, believing that their safety and worthiness of belonging comes from avoiding being shamed and blamed by placing that blame on someone else. Safety through perpetration and persecution. Safety through numbness. There are collective memories at different points in our history that illustrate this such as: the Persecution of Witches, the Magdalene Laundries, Collaborator Horizontal, amongst others.
This entanglement kicks in between mothers and their children. The mothers in the field of influence who cast out their pregnant or ‘different’ daughters, who shame their sons, who are running an internal belief that being ‘good’ is safer than love. This wounding response is a painful legacy that is ubiquitous in the field and its silenced roots are entrenched in
the untold collective stories of the persecution of the feminine. It is why there can be such fear of making a mistake. It is the intersection of the ‘good girl entanglement’ and the
‘scarlet women’. The cost of the punishments placed on previous generations becomes the inheritance that the descendants live with.
Divorce and the Good Girl
Divorce is an interesting piece to work with when exploring collective memories. In western society over half of all marriages end in divorce and divorce is now generally thought of as commonplace. But it is a very recent phenomenon. It is only in the last few decades that it has been possible for women to petition for divorce; in certain faiths it was forbidden and would have been a devastating and shameful event for both families involved. The historical narrative of divorce trauma is why, even in cases of an amicable divorce, there is such a strong response to it from the surrounding family and ancestral fields.
The reasons for this strong field response to divorce are complex. Perhaps in some cases it is the first divorce in the family that has been petitioned by a woman. In previous generations this would have been impossible. Divorce would have been perceived as being dangerous, particularly for the woman, and the loss of name, land, place, and belonging can appear in the constellation with a pull to unseen, silent, excluded and forbidden women, with a resulting separation and exclusion from the family’s belief system. There may also be a narrative of punishment and shame flowing silently through the field of influence.
The usefulness and immediacy of effect of constellation in supporting individuals through the painful process of divorce always strikes me. I have worked with countless clients at various points of the separation and divorce journey and seen constellation transform something that has been crushing, excluding, and often intractable, into something more peaceful, with a space for resolution and belonging.
The impact and cost of divorce within the constellation setting, in terms of emotional belonging and freedom, is far greater on women than on men. I do not mean to say that divorce is easier on men than on women or that there isn’t an emotional cost to men. What I am saying is that within the invisible structure of our culture, society and families, the invisible ‘agreements’ relating to divorce and what it means to be a woman who chooses it or experiences it in any way is loaded with inherited legacies, agreements and beliefs.
Cost of divorce in the ancestral field
For many of our previous generations, a wife was considered the property of her husband in the UK, US, and Europe. She passed from the place as a child under the authority of a father or brother, to the place as a wife under the authority of her husband. This changed gradually but it took a long time. After divorce she could still not own property, even inherited property, earn money or have access to her children. She could not take back any property or wealth that she had entered the relationship with. Anything she earned would go back to her husband. It remained this way until 1887. This too gradually changed but there was significant stigma and it was not common for a divorced woman to be able to have a recognised subsequent relationship.
Men could divorce women, in 1857, before women could divorce men. They could divorce women for adultery and also have them institutionalised. Women needed adultery plus another action, such as desertion for two years or physical cruelty in order to instigate proceedings, and this was made very difficult. Divorce was mainly for the wealthy.
Even in the UK, before Independent Taxation was introduced in 1990, the income of a married woman living with her husband was treated for Income Tax purposes as his income and he was responsible for her tax. Today, the Catholic Church still refuses to acknowledge divorce in the spiritual sense. They believe that once you are married in the church, you are married forever.
The impact of this on the descendants is huge, particularly for women. Women in the present, in the throes of divorce, can find themselves cast out of their own sense of self, out of their very belonging. Friendships, family, and working relationships can change as the lens of the past comes into force. They can find themselves unseen for who they actually are and viewed with suspicion – an energetic return to the place of a child under the father or brother’s charge, which is a wholly disconcerting experience. There are obvious present generation and relationship dynamics to be worked with in a divorce constellation. However, it is imperative to consider the collective ancestral memories around it.
The loss of place, name, children, autonomy, property, wealth, reputation, and sometimes freedom for the ancestors translates to deep entanglements around the fear of such experiences in the descendants. This influences not just the woman who finds herself in the midst of divorce but also those around her, in all areas of her life. For her, love itself may become dangerous and tainted, from some of those around her. She herself has become the threat.
Ella’s Story
I explored the legacy of divorce in the ancestral field in a recent collective memory constellation group. The story we worked with was Ella Sinclair’s and her descendants in the present, who had also experienced a painful divorce from an abusive partner.
Ella was married to Alfred Sinclair and they had a young son together. Their marriage was happy until Alfred returned from serving in WWI. He returned a changed man. He was violent and abusive. He wanted out of the marriage and had begun to have an affair. Ella sought support from her own parents and her husband’s but she was advised to turn a blind eye.
Alfred started divorce proceedings against her. At that time, in 1925, Ella had very few rights. Divorce was not yet common and the power resided with the husbands. The divorce was petitioned citing Ella as mentally incompetent and an unfit mother. She lost access to her son and was institutionalised for a number of years. Her parents abandoned her, and her in-laws took Alfred and his new partner’s side in the unfolding events.
The constellation was set up to include:
- Ella Sinclair
- Alfred Sinclair
- Ella’s parents
- Alfred’s parents
- Alfred’s new partner
- Ella and Alfred’s son Divorce
- Descendants in the Present Belonging
- Love
- Beliefs
There was so much silence and pain in this constellation. Alfred, who petitioned the divorce from Ella could only see himself and his own pain. He was unable to see outside of himself. There was also a significant amount of negative focus on Ella from all of the other representatives, particularly her parents. However, none was shown towards Alfred.
The descendants in the present also initially didn’t want to look at any of it and couldn’t bring themselves to engage with Ella. Ella described a huge sense of pain, shame, and grief. She felt as though she had failed. She didn’t feel comfortable or safe looking at the descendants.
The woman that Alfred went on to be with was also very perpetrating towards Ella and wanted her place.
“You don’t exist anymore. I am Mrs Sinclair.”
Both Alfred’s and Ella’s parents were numbed out with pain. Ella’s parents were ashamed of Ella. The cost to them and their family was perceived as too great and they would not acknowledge her existence. The divorce representative was full of rage and unmet grief.
Initially neither of the parents could see the descendants in the present either. However, after Ella spoke again of her pain, saying: “I failed. This is worse than death. Please don’t look at me,” there was a shift in the field.
After hearing Ella talk about her deep sense of failure and shame, the representative for the descendants in the present was moved to say to Ella:
“There were children. I am here because there were children. Your love still matters.”
This began the shift within the field and Alfred’s mother came forward out of the shadows of her own husband. She was now able to see the descendants and Ella. The mother described being in a prison-like state herself and having a compassionate response to Ella and the descendants in the present, but not knowing how to reach them. She wasn’t free to reach out to any of them until the phrase: “Your love still matters,” was spoken.
This is a significant movement and is the beginning of the breaking of the belief that love is dangerous and in particular that the love from a ‘shamed’ woman is dangerous.
The field opened up further when Ella heard the descendants in the present talk about love. She was mesmerised when they spoke of mistakes being made and that they weren’t a death sentence or a prison anymore.
I have made mistakes and I am still worthy of love
have made mistakes and I am still worthy of my life
I have made mistakes and I am still worthy of my children
There is a place for mistakes
The mistakes are sacred too
I am vulnerable
The vulnerability is not shameful
The realisation that the children were living a different life tended a wound within Ella.
In many divorce constellations there is a real and deep fear of being associated with the divorced or accused women, as if the shame of it all would be contagious. This undoubtedly has threads back to the ‘witch persecution’ memories and the persecution of the feminine.
Another significant entangled layer in this constellation was between the ‘imprisoned’ women – the mother-in-law who was imprisoned by her marriage and Ella who was physically institutionalised as well as trapped in the cost of marriage and divorce.
This collective memory of mental, emotional, and often physical imprisonment or institutionalisation is a silent and insidious inherited wound. It was released within this map for both Ella and her mother-in-law when the descendants in the present were able to say that they had escaped their own abusive marriage.
I got out.
I refuse to go quietly into the unseen.
I refuse to go quietly into the voiceless.
You are no longer bound to them.
Your soul is free.
Death has taken the promises.
Death has taken the vows.
Death has taken the denouncement.
I know a different love.
I am here because there was more than death.
I know a different love.
I got out.
I am not running.
I am sitting with you in this place.
Grief has broken me open too.
I am sitting in the stillness.
And it isn’t death.
This not only soothed the ancestors, but it also soothed the descendants in the present. The fear, pain, shame, and grief are entangled. Along with the belief that there can only be one love, one choice of love and a lifetime of aloneness and punishment if it fails. Failure was a word with a big presence in this, and other divorce constellations. There was a deep sense of shameful failure associated with it that ‘belonged’ with the women, regardless of their actions. It was hard to sit with for many in the group, in part because it is so familiar.
There was a further movement between the descendants, Ella, and her mother-in-law with the descendants saying the words:
I am beginning to know your unspoken story
I feel how dangerous it was to hope
I feel how dangerous it was to dream
I feel how dangerous it was to love
I am tending my own dreams and joy
It isn’t a call to death
I have been holding this fear as mine
I feel the agreement not to remember you
I am breaking it
I want to remember you
Your love and courage still matter
I can feel them
And I remember there was also joy
I still feel your love
I know love
The reassurance for Ella that her love still mattered was transformational, not just for her but for her descendants too. Whispering the phrases; “Your love mattered. Your love still matters. I can still feel your love,” to the unseen, voiceless, and displaced women in the ancestral field is a powerful offering.
For women going through the process of divorce and finding themselves emotionally, physically and spiritually displaced, it can be a destructive and unexpected root of trauma that becomes entangled with the past trauma of divorce in the field. Add to that the historical associations and cost of divorce within the collective historical narrative, particularly around belief and belonging, and you have a heady emotional and traumatic mix.
Allowing a place for grief is critical and it is transformative. Honouring grief and tending it actually creates a bigger place for living, for joy, hope and dreams. But sitting with grief is hard. Acknowledging our personal grief is hard, particularly when we are entangled with the ungrieved grief of the ancestors. It is this ungrieved grief that we sit with knowingly or unknowingly. Divorce is a small piece in this collective experience of female voicelessness, but it is a tangible and accessible one to work with.
Sitting with the stories and looking beyond the bitterness to give place to the grief, looking beyond the courage of the pioneering, difficult women to give place to the cost. Telling the parts of the stories that were silenced then, frees the descendants of those souls now. There are ripples of silences, once held tightly, breaking open – vows and promises released and a space for the individual to become free to take their own place outside of the inherited legacy of voicelessness.
A Ghost in the Throat
How painful it is to exist without voice. To be forgotten. Erased. Deemed unworthy. It is the choking feeling in the throat. The thumping of a heart. The feeling of the overwhelming need to escape, be anywhere and anyone other than what resides in the present moment. The knowing that something is very wrong indeed but not knowing what to do about it, how to even ask for help.
When women in the family and ancestral field are rendered voiceless because of the beliefs associated with what it means to be a ‘good girl’, it marks the subsequent generations, of all genders. When there is either a continuance of the acceptance of the voicelessness – by assuming that they have nothing of worth to say, or a continuance of holding the judgements placed upon them – by accepting the single story of their bitterness or ‘badness’, then we effectively render aspects of ourselves voiceless. We mute, deny, punish, and cast out the parts of ourselves that aren’t ‘good enough’, but not only that, we do that to those around us, those whom we love, and we leave it as a legacy for those generations that come after.
Voicing the unspoken stories, screaming the unscreamed screams is not an easy task but it is a brave, courageous, and important one. Speaking up and saying the previously unspoken ‘No!’ or the unuttered ‘Yes!’ begins the release not only of the individual in question but also the generations before them, and the generations yet to come. We can each scream those unscreamed screams so they don’t have to. We can also say to those women that their love matters.
REFERENCES
Houston, M., & Kramarae, C. (1991) Speaking from silence: methods of silencing and of resistance. Discourse & Society, Amsterdam, Netherlands.
Jackson, L. (1995) Witches, wives and mothers: witchcraft persecution and women’s confessions in seventeenth-century England. Women’s History Review, 4:1, 63-84. Portsmouth, UK.
Leopold, T. (2018) Gender Differences in the Consequences of Divorce: A Study of Multiple Outcomes. Demography, Durham, USA.
Mackay, N. (2020) Your Invisible Inheritance. Rebel Magic Books, London, UK.
Wood, M. (2018) Marriage and Divorce 19th Century Style. The Law Library of Congress, Washington D.C., USA.
Sharma, B. (2011) Mental and Emotional Impact of Divorce on Women. Journal of the Indian Academy of Applied Psychology, Gujarat, India.
Thurlow K.M. (2016) Blurring The Lines between Collaboration and Resistance: Women in Nazi Germany and Vichy and Nazi-Occupied France. Dissertations, Theses, and Masters Projects. W&M Scholar Works, Florida, USA.