Those who left and the Left Behind: A Liminal Space
|
Getting your Trinity Audio player ready...
|
Estimated Reading Time: 25 minutes
Those who left are also left behind, and those left behind have also left. The pain of this entanglement, and the wounds inflicted by it, pass from generation to generation; morphing, growing, and mutating with each iteration. It encompasses migration trauma, war trauma, and the fracturing of families. It is bound up with the fragility of safety, love, hopes, and dreams – the fragility of life itself.
Those who left are also left behind, as part of their heart stays with who and what they have left behind – those they love, their home, the life and dreams that they have lived and tended. And those left behind have also left because part of them goes with those who have left and part of them goes to the memory of ‘what was’ in this place that they now find themselves.
It is an immense pain, a ragged wound that splits souls and hearts open. It can define families, communities, countries – it can define a generation. The lost youth of WWI, those boys and men who left and are also left behind. Bodies in the ground in the battlefields and hearts left at home with the world that once was. The mothers, fathers, siblings, lovers, grandparents left behind and who also left their present, to have their hearts travel with those they have lost and into that past that existed before the ripping apart.
It is the moment for many when peace dies, when safety dies – and for some, when their beliefs and their relationship with God dies. Belonging and sense of place is also lost when grief cannot be formed and given a place. So often the grief cannot be given a place because of the very vastness of what is lost between the separate but inextricably linked those who left and the left behind.
The seeing and not seeing of pain and trauma, the actual cost of seeing and sitting with the pain and the ungrieved grief, is immense. It is in this space that the fears of our ancestors collapse into our own – the remembering of our ancestors’ pain and ungrieved grief in our own present grief and pain. It is exhausting this weight of seeing and not seeing.
So often the grief cannot be given a place because of the very vastness of what is lost between the separate but inextricably linked those who left and the left behind.
The images of war-torn Ukraine, the women and children being pressed on to trains, kissing goodbye to their partners, brothers, sons. The seeing of these scenes and the unfolding conflict collapses us into the past. Parts of us can begin to view the present through our ancestors’ past.
Many times in constellation sessions I have used the phrase: “This isn’t then,” to separate out the past from the present story or experience. It is harder to access the separation and acknowledge the shift that usually comes with the use of that phrase in these present times. Because in many ways this does feel like then.
Exploring Collective Memories and Untold Stories
Since 2016 I have been working with Prof. K.M. Fierke, researching the effect of unacknowledged collective traumatic memory on present-day politics and conflict. In 2020, at the start of the pandemic, we were supported by the Human Family Unity Foundation to expand our research. Our initial focus was on exploring the legacy of empire on present-day politics, in part through the lens of the pandemic.
Topics explored have ranged from the European refugee crisis, the normalisation of the politics of hate, the impact of past memories of collective trauma showing up as influence on and effect of Brexit, climate change response, the pandemic itself, and many others. All of the constellation mapping is conducted blind. The results have been interesting and encouraging, regarding the potential for constellation as a tool in this arena.
What our findings have also highlighted, repeatedly in map after map, is the significance of the unacknowledged dead, ungrieved grief, and of unacknowledged guilt. Those three aspects appear time and again in the collective context. It shouldn’t be a surprise as constellation facilitators see it every day within the individual and family context.
Grief, Guilt, and the Dead
Ungrieved grief is not a benign phenomenon, and if left ungrieved and unmet, it morphs into unacknowledged guilt. The unacknowledged dead remain displaced and unseen.
The prevalence of ungrieved grief in the collective context is incomprehensibly large – the need to not see, not remember, not feel, to numb out grief and pain. And yet the numbing out leads us on to guilt and unacknowledged guilt. The legacy of this guilt becomes an unwanted inheritance for the next generation. The guilt of surviving when others did not is passed down to, and placed upon, the children. Not only that, when we have these three root aspects of unacknowledged guilt, ungrieved grief, and unacknowledged dead entangled together, it creates the need for safety outside of seeing, witnessing, knowing and feeling. The ungrieved grief becomes exacerbated and a perpetrator response, a war narrative, comes in as a ‘false safety’ and it is indeed a false safety.
Bringing in a representative space for safety or peace in a constellation map can be a provocative act within the informing field, particularly within a collective memory constellation, because it is subjective. Safety within the boundaries of entanglements is not universal. Safety and peace for one representative may mean the exact opposite for the other. So what can we bring in to support a compassionate response, an aspect of seeing that is not a war narrative or perpetrator response within the field? We can bring in ‘tending the future of children’, a seeing of the children and the generations yet to come. That is the closest to a universal safety that we have found.
The ability to have a compassionate response in the present moment when we are surrounded by ancestral experiences, or the lived and present reality, of those who left/are left behind and those left behind/have left is directly linked to our own ability to see that painful wound within our individual, family, community, and cultural fields. It is no small thing. I have walked with this many times and the wounds are deep and entrenched.
Untold Stories from Ukraine
In December 2019, as part of a project with the HFU Foundation and Chris Halas Wood, to explore the roots of racism within the USA, we facilitated a series of group constellations exploring the legacy of migration trauma within the USA.
There was a significant number of attendees who were the descendants of Ukrainian and Russian ancestors. Over the course of our time together we set up several constellation maps to uncover and acknowledge migration trauma entanglements.
One of the participants, Sara, shared the story of her Grandmother, Rebecca. As a young newly-wedded woman, Rebecca left the Ukraine to go to the US with her Ukrainian husband at the beginning of WWI. Before she left, her mother made her promise that she would return to Ukraine after she had made a home for herself in the US. She went back to Ukraine to fulfil that promise to her mother and then returned to the US again. Her husband returned with her but refused to leave Ukraine again. Rebecca returned to the US leaving them behind and her mother and husband were murdered in the Babyn Yar (1) massacre during WWII. Rebecca had eight siblings. She managed to persuade some of them to leave for safety in the US but four stayed behind. The resulting constellation revealed entanglements that are still alive today in the present conflict, and they epitomise the deep wound that is those who left/are left behind and those left behind/have left.
Representatives included:
- Sara
- Descendants in the present
- Rebecca
- Rebecca’s Mother
- Rebecca’s Father
- Ukraine
- Rebecca’s Husband
- Promise to go back to Ukraine
- Land in US
- Those left behind
- Persecution
- Those that didn’t survive
- Children
- Belonging
- Murder
- Rebecca’s maternal ancestors
- Rebecca’s paternal ancestors
- The Dead
- Safety
- A different belonging
- Silence
- Debt
The representative for Ukraine immediately stepped out to the edges of the constellation space – isolated, observing and silent.
Persecution looked at Descendants in the present, becoming fixated on them.
Rebecca’s parents looked away from this interaction, they could not bear to see the Descendants in the present. This is a common entanglement present in war and conflict trauma. The weight of what was lost and the entanglements of those who left and those left behind can render an inability, or refusal to see the continuation of a lineage.
Rebecca’s mother described feeling that she didn’t know where she belonged; she had lost a sense of herself.
Persecution and Murder gradually became drawn to one another, moving slowly.
Ukraine became angry and agitated as the constellation unfolded.
The representatives for Children were drawn towards the Ukraine representative but Ukraine couldn’t see them. This is a collective example of the wound of the ‘those who left and those left behind’ entanglement.
The ancestors stood behind Rebecca’s mother, and they could see the Descendants in the present. However, they were more aware of Perpetration. They weren’t connected to Rebecca, exacerbating the sense of displacement within her.
Rebecca’s father was detached from his ancestors and was feeling sad and angry. The ancestors said to him: “I don’t want to be here” and at this point, Those that didn’t survive lay down. This was an indication of entanglements with the unacknowledged dead and unacknowledged guilt within Rebecca’s paternal line. It was a fractured line. A further representative for The Dead was added to lie down beside Those that didn’t survive, as the weight of the presence there was so great. Ukraine was drawn to them, as was Persecution.
Those that didn’t survive being seen by both Ukraine and Persecution was frightening for the representatives of Those left behind and they said:
“I am trying to hide. Don’t look for me. Don’t remember.”
At this point a defensive cluster formed, comprising of:
- Ukraine
- Promise to go back to the Ukraine
- Rebecca
- The Dead
- Those that didn’t survive
The representatives for the Descendants in the present felt guilty and disconnected because of the weight of the ungrieved grief in the field. They spoke from the weight of that entanglement and the carrying of unacknowledged guilt within them was clear:
“I am guilty. I survived. It is hard to look at you. I believed it would kill me.”
Rebecca’s mother cried at this movement and a little of the grief began to shift.
This allowed the representative for Belonging to move to stand behind the representatives for the Descendants in the present. This was a significant shift and a supportive one – when this fracturing entanglement is held tightly, belonging for the Descendants in the present can often only be found through a connection with the unacknowledged dead.
A representative was added for Safety at this point. This created a movement with Rebecca’s mother. She began to look towards and see Those left behind and Ukraine. She also began to feel resentment towards her husband, describing him as being in the way of her being able to see Those left behind – an indication of the subjective nature of safety even within an individual context.
It became clear that from the perspective of Rebecca’s mother, Those left behind were her first loyalty – a promise made to her own lineage before the relationship with her husband. She had left her home in Eastern Ukraine to be with her husband in the West. Rebecca had been carrying that loss and fracture for her.
Rebecca’s mother was eventually able to say to Those left behind:
“I didn’t want to leave you. Part of me stayed. You have my heart. You were my first promise.”
A representative was then placed for A different belonging and that eased the entangled connection with Ukraine and Those left behind. Rebecca’s maternal ancestors were full of regret for not getting out sooner.
Rebecca’s mother spoke from the entangled grief saying:
“This killed me. This wasn’t love. This killed me.”
There was a significant emotional release for Rebecca’s mother in being able to break her silence. The representative for the Promise to go back to the Ukraine that Rebecca made to her mother gravitated towards Rebecca’s mother, further indicating that the promise originated with her mother and not Rebecca – it was an inheritance.
Those left behind began to move towards the representative for A different belonging. This provoked Silence to move towards the Children and block them.
No one is seeing the Children or the Descendants in the present at this point. The field is isolated and fractured with the weight of the silence and the broken promises. The safety included within the constellation map is not safety for everyone.
When the inclusion of Safety provokes a movement into not seeing of Children it is an indication that death is being held as an aspect of safety. A belief that death is perhaps the only safety and survival is untenable. This leaves deep marks on the descendants for many generations as they unconsciously believe that their very lives are a betrayal.
The Constellation Field was split into different entangled loyalties. Rebecca’s father was entangled with the Ukraine representative and the land there. And Rebecca’s mother was entangled with Those left behind, relating to her land of origin, and her first promise.
At this point, Rebecca’s mother could see and connect with the dead but there was an anger between them:
“I hate you. I blame you. I don’t want to see you.”
There was no compassion present and a perpetration narrative emerged instead as a false safety. The anger expressed in this context indicated an inherited belief that Rebecca’s mother was responsible for holding the unlived years and fulfilling the unlived dreams of the unacknowledged dead.
Rebecca was confused by the expressions of anger and felt trapped by her mother; she too was tethered to the ancestral broken promises. She faced her mother:
“I did this for you. Please see me. Please love me.”
The Descendants in the present moved to witness the exchange. It created a further movement within the Mother who described the terrible things happening around her and that she needed to choose that:
“You have to keep the promise. I can’t love you. It isn’t safe.”
She then repeated to her husband:
“I can’t love you. It isn’t safe. My heart has already died.”
This is another common entanglement in migration trauma and the descendants that come from it, epitomised by an internalised inherited belief that love is dangerous and often tainted. It is incredibly painful and leaves wounds on subsequent generations.
The representative for Perpetration was emboldened by the naming of the entangled belief by Rebecca’s mother, and moved towards Those left behind stating:
“I own you.”
Those left behind replied:
“I’ll kill you.”
There was a disturbing enslavement pattern here with an inability to see the dead or the children. That pattern was holding both Perpetration and Those left behind within the entanglement. The representative for Murder then wrapped their arms around Those left behind. There was a struggle between them. Those that didn’t survive and the Dead were pushed further away, becoming more unseen, as Perpetration, Those left behind and Murder stayed in a perpetration dynamic within the historical narrative of war. This is a false safety and there is a deep cost to it.
Those that didn’t survive were physically moved to Those left behind in an effort to shift the Field out of the ‘war as safety’ narrative, and for the Dead to be seen. Unfortunately, there was still a refusal to see the Dead. Perpetration began to see the Children but tried to deny their place:
“When I look at you it costs too much. You can’t be children. You can’t be innocent.”
They were looking at the children through the unacknowledged dead, unacknowledged guilt, and the ungrieved grief.
The Children said:
“I am children. I am innocent. I existed. I lived. I breathed. I lived. I died.”
The representatives for the Children then repeated this to the rest of the created constellation space.
Rebecca’s mother became agitated by this:
“I hear them. I can’t love you. It costs too much.”
This again, is the entanglement with the unacknowledged dead, unacknowledged guilt, and the ungrieved grief. The Descendants in the present, however, gradually shifted and were able to see and to say to the Children:
“I see you. I have lived you. Part of me comes from you. I feel you waiting to be seen and loved. I have been waiting with you. I believed I had to be you. I am not you but I can see you.”
This provoked a significant shift and relaxation in the Field. The Children began to be seen and the Descendants experienced the beginnings of a shift within their belonging. The sacrifice of the children was held as a silent secret and the lack of safety in love, what love means, and the children’s suffering of the trauma is the inheritance at play in the present descendants. It is underpinned by the weight of the unacknowledged dead, unacknowledged guilt, and the ungrieved grief.
This movement allowed the Descendants to release themselves from the Ancestors who were still waiting for their dreams to be fulfilled. A lineage of women from present generation to five generations back were able to release the broken promises and see one another. However, the Ukraine representative was still deeply agitated. The Children were seen but the Dead, and Those that did not survive, were still not seen and Those left behind were still very active. From the Descendants in the present’s perspective, enough had moved to allow them to begin to face their future:
“There is more than death here. I can choose to live.”
The individual intersected with the collective here, and only the individual context shifted. The historical narrative of the original promises that were linked to land, war, and fracturing remained. There were indications within the map, of influences from inherited political loyalties for Ukraine and between Ukraine and Russia/Poland.
Collective Inheritance of Contracts, Secrets, and Betrayals
We explored this collective aspect further in a subsequent constellation and there were some deeply entangled roots. This was particularly active around the cost of the Russian Draft (conscription was compulsory for all males over 21 and was for a period of years) and the avoidance of it, an added collective weight of guilt between Those who left and Those left behind.
The increased presence of perpetration within the map was striking. The representative for the Draft slowly moved towards Those who left, saying:
“I own you, I own your guilt, I don’t care whose blood, I just want blood.”
This lack of compassionate response indicated a deeper conflict and perpetration entanglement around betrayal and broken promises. It continued when Those who avoided the Draft said:
“No. I am not coming back.”
The Draft responded with:
“I already have you.
I own you.
You owe me.
You owe me blood.
I just want the blood.”
This was disturbing and emotive within the map. There was significant tension within all represented spaces and it was another indication of entangled broken promises between Ukraine and Russia.
Those who avoided the Draft then said:
“I’m not coming back.
You can’t have me.
You can’t have my children.”
The Draft responded with:
“I already own your children.”
Another representative for Those who avoided the draft became very distressed by this, stating they were worried that the words spoken by the Draft were true and that they never actually escaped. This is an aspect of an entanglement around the cost of survival – the weight of the unacknowledged guilt, grief, and dead that is passed to the children when it is unseen in the present – a toxic legacy.
A representative for Debt spoke to the Draft:
“Forget me. I want you to forget my promise.”
This is an older entanglement of broken promises speaking but the Draft refused to acknowledge it. The Descendants in the present were very distressed and displaced by this. Similar to Rebecca’s mother in the earlier map, they were drawn to the Dead and the weight of the guilt and ungrieved grief.
“I’ve lost my place.
I don’t know who I am.
I can’t remember who I am.
I can’t remember my name.
I can’t remember my land.
I can’t remember who I am.”
The Draft representative was satisfied and comforted by this. The perpetration response as a false safety was active. They stated:
“You owe me this.”
Then to Those who left:
“I’ll take them instead.”
The representative for Guilt stated that they wished they had chosen death rather than this. The cost of survival was huge here and there was a fracture between Those who left and Those left behind that is complicated by the historical narrative of the broken promise between Ukraine and Russia that existed before this draft.
Those Left Behind said to Those Who Left:
“I need your life to be my life. I claim it.”
This is clearly an entanglement holding both aspects in a liminal space. The need for safety through perpetration was entrenched within the map and appeared, again, to be older than the draft.
The Draft shifted at this point to say to Those left behind:
“They left you.”
This changed the Field and Those left behind began to weep; the grief was finally breaking open. The Draft saw this grief response and softened a little:
“Your grief is like my grief. Your dead are with my dead.”
This movement created a place for grief where it had previously been denied.
However, Those who couldn’t avoid the draft were still stuck within the actual avoidance of it, the contract was still active for them and their descendants. They were able to break the guilty silence and secrecy around this and say:
“I didn’t agree to beyond this life.
I didn’t agree to forever.
I didn’t agree to my children taking my place.
I didn’t agree to give you my soul.
My soul is my own.
You’ve stolen my soul – I want it back.”
This shifted the focus to Those who left and the Descendants in the present.
The weight of the guilt was overwhelming for the Descendants in the present and in spite of the ancestors of both Those who left and Those left behind saying:
“Please live. Please live,” they found it very difficult to separate and take their place. They were holding the weight of the unacknowledged dead, guilt, and grief from the original root entanglement and trauma. It was only when Secrets stood with Descendants in
the present that they could move away. This was a release, but it did not clear the root collective entanglement.
The constellation was stopped at this point after supporting the representatives for Descendants in the present to drop into the individual Field and say:
“I am going to live. I am alive now.”
A Lived Legacy
This pain and grief is in each one of us as we witness – or not – the present unfolding trauma in Afghanistan, Yemen, Ukraine and others. As we find ourselves in the midst of the ‘cost of living crisis’, scarcity fears, the deep uncertainty of climate change and of war, we are plunged into the entanglements of our ancestors. And not only that, we feel their rip away from safety at moments in our own lives when we lose, or prepare to lose, safety. When a loved one dies, a relationship ends, a dream is lost, we embody that fracture of those who left/are left behind and those left behind/have left. Sometimes we hold it internally within our souls. The rip between who we were before and who we are after trauma. The parts of ourselves that we leave behind with what we lost and the attempt to numb out the part of us that stays, trying to find a solid footing in a world that is not the same as the one we have lost.
We need to tend this sacred wound of those who left/are left behind and those left behind/have left because it is being laid bare in our collective. Our world is changing in big and little ways and the ghosts of the ancestors’ untold stories have been stirred. It costs a lot to grieve this wound but it costs more not to. And if we don’t tend the wound, instead of tending a future for our children we are leaving them the continued unwanted inheritance of unmet grief, unacknowledged guilt, and unacknowledged dead.
We are living through a period of time that will be remembered in history. It is imperative to tend the grief, pain, guilt, loss, and trauma that is happening now. We know more today about transgenerational inheritance of trauma than our ancestors did. Our ancestors could not stop and had to keep going to survive. We are therefore still knowingly or unknowingly living their untended wounds. We can break the pattern of inherited trauma by choosing to pause, feel and witness what is, as it moves through each one of us.
I have been working with the ache of this around my own responses to the world we are currently living in, as well as with clients and groups. Sitting with the spaces of the unacknowledged dead, ungrieved grief and unacknowledged guilt along with a space for tending the future of children, is a small offering.
I work with speaking the following phrases to all those spaces:
Your pain matters
Your grief matters
Your beliefs matter
Your love matters
Your lives matter
Your children matter
Your dreams matter
Your hopes matter
What you have lost matters
I see you, and I am not the only one
I am grieving, and I am not the only one
The grief has a place and there is more than grief
This doesn’t have to become then.
Stopping, pausing, breathing into the pain, grief, and loss – sitting with it – is important. This is the medicine. If we do not do this then the children, the next generations, will have to do it for us.
NOTES:
1. Babyn Yar – also known as Babi Yar – is one of the largest World War Two mass graves in Europe. The massacre of 33,771 Jews at the ravine on the outskirts of Kyiv took place over two days in September 1941. As the Holocaust continued, German forces continued to perpetrate crimes at Babyn Yar, using it as a mass grave to dispose of up to 100,000 bodies, until the Soviets took control of Kyiv again in 1943. As well as Jews, Roma, Ukrainian civilians and Soviet prisoners of war were also murdered there.
REFERENCES
Boccagni, P. (2015) Emotions on the Move: Mapping the Emergent Field of Emotion and Migration. Emotion, Space and Society, Stockholm, Sweden.
Fierke, K.M. & Mackay, N. (2020) To See is to Break an Entanglement: Quantum Measurement, Trauma and Security. Security Dialogue, Ottawa, Canada.
Hellinger, B. (2003) Farewell: Family Constellations with Descendants of Victims and Perpetrators. Carl-Auer-Systeme-Verlag, Heidelberg, Germany.
Berkhoff, K.C. (2008) Babi Yar Massacre. The Shoah in Ukraine: History, Testimony, Memorialization, Indiana University Press, Indiana, USA.
Mackay, N. (2020) Your Invisible Inheritance, Rebel Magic Books, London, UK.
Marchetti-Mercer, M. (2012) Those Easily Forgotten: The Impact of Emigration on Those Left Behind. Family Process, Philadelphia, USA.
Sanborn, J. (1997) Conscription, Correspondence, and Politics in Late Imperial Russia. Russian History, Leiden, Netherlands.