The Silent Legacy of ‘Not Enough to Keep the Children Safe’
|
Getting your Trinity Audio player ready...
|
Estimated Reading Time: 20 minutes
Stories are important. They are part of our life blood. They hold our love, our hopes and dreams, and also, they hold who we are and were, who our ancestors were. Stories define our world and our place in it. In the moment that a story or voice falls silent, something or someone else can fill that silence. The story can be claimed, taken, often erased or excluded. And the part of an individual or their lineage entangled with that story becomes voiceless and displaced along with the silence. The souls within the story become unseen, and when they are unseen they cannot be grieved. The silence and the displaced grief become a heavy inheritance for the generations that follow.
Collective stories and memories are significant on both an individual and cultural basis. They have an emotional charge, and knowingly or unknowingly help to define the structure of who we are. They bind us to the story of what was and what is, in relation to individual and collective remembering. They also inform beliefs of who and what is worthy of grief, and who and what is not.
As we connect with those memories, we are reanimating them within us. Our sense of belonging is enhanced by this individual and collective honouring and remembrance. When our voice or story, or our ancestors’ voices and stories, become silenced in any way then we can believe ourselves, and them, not worthy of remembrance.
In the period encompassing the height of the Irish Famine, 1845-1849, over two million souls died or left Ireland. That was around a quarter of the population at that time, a huge number of people. The individual stories that make up this collective memory are heart-breaking and littered with betrayal from state, church and government. The events that run through the veins of this collective experience were hammer blows that fractured families and lineages. The stories are also largely silent, voiceless, and unacknowledged.
When we step into connection with the known and unknown collective stories of our ancestors, we experience the emotional intricacies of entanglements that are not our own and that are also bigger than us as individuals. We feel the resonance between us and them, where the stories intertwine with our own. This allows the invisible influences – our invisible inheritance – to be made visible. This is the inherited ‘knowing’ of our ancestors.
Our experiencing of them, our remembering of their stories, is an offering to our ancestors, ourselves, our communities, and also our descendants. The grieving of a collective trauma is to tell the stories of what was lost, so that the souls that make up that story are not denied their place. And in doing so, we reveal and gather missing pieces from our own souls. We step into the sacred.
The first time I knowingly stepped into a group constellation to explore collective memories of the Irish famine had a very specific focus to it. It was part of a series of workshops exploring the roots of racism and slavery within the USA in 2019. In attempting to explore the unseen and unacknowledged trauma potentially impacting the ability of an individual in the present to ‘see’ enslavement and racism, we chose to explore the possible collective memories from historical European migration to the USA that the gathered group brought with them through their ancestral field. When someone is able to look back at who their ancestors were, the unexplored and untold stories of where they come from, then it shifts their ability to ‘see’ and engage with what is ‘unseen’ in their present. We were looking to tell the stories that hadn’t been told relating to the collective memories from the group’s ancestral field. One of those collective memories was the Irish Famine in the 1840s. It was a deeply moving and highly emotive experience.
I have to confess I had no real sense of the Irish Famine, its significance, its causes or its consequences until I bumped up against it a few times in various constellation settings, and this I now know was part of my own ancestral entanglements. In Scotland, where I live, it is often referred to colloquially as the ‘Tattie Famine’ without a great deal of compassion or credence given to the trauma or the experiences encompassed within it. The vastness of the trauma and the unseen and silent nature of it is really exceptional. In my own exploration of it as a collective memory I uncovered ancestors from Southern Ireland, their stories unspoken in my family too.
Ireland was the first colony of the British Empire and the desire to place a version of Britain upon Ireland is a legacy that is still felt in our present day. The carving out of the Ulster plantations in the North in the 1600s, the Famine in the 1800s, the Irish Rebellion in the early 1900s, followed by Irish neutrality in WW2, and then the ‘Troubles’. These are all wounds of Empire that are still bleeding today.
Beginning to see through the blind spots
I set up the first group constellation map by asking the folk who had Irish ancestry to represent their ancestors, with a couple of them being asked to represent the descendants in the present. I also brought in representatives for children, mothers, fathers and the unseen to allow the stories to begin to reveal themselves. And they certainly did.
The weight of the trauma within the created Constellation Field was immediate and the representatives for the Irish ancestors were quickly overwhelmed by it. One representative for ‘mothers’ screamed: “NO!” and it seemed to echo and reverberate around the room. It was an embodiment of an ‘un-screamed scream’ and the visceral breaking of an ancestral silence. It was spontaneous and directly from her entangled state within the memory. She was looking for her children but couldn’t see them. The representatives for the children were at the edge of the constellation space, and the mother simply had no awareness of them and although they could see her, they could not move towards her. They were each stuck and entangled.
This inability to see the children within the created constellation was consistent for the majority of representatives within the created Field. It has also shown up repeatedly in other collective memory constellations I have facilitated since then, and there is a deep significance to that experience of ‘not seeing’ that we will discuss further.
Some of the representatives for the Irish ancestors within the constellation had completely fractured all belonging of themselves to ‘Ireland’ and would not look at the dead, nor the children, the innocents or their own responsibilities. Their safety and belonging were derived from not seeing and not remembering. One representative spoke directly from the entanglement:
I lost all that I have.
I lost all that I was.
I need to escape the pain. I can’t look at you.
I can’t see you.
It is killing me too.
I need to survive.
The children called out to them:
Please don’t leave.
Please don’t go.
Those are deeply wounded words, and they are also entanglements.
It was painful to witness but the value of the children’s trauma being so unseen and unacknowledged is healing within the Constellation Field space. Seeing this entanglement, this collectively held vow to ‘not see’, really witnessing it, can begin the process of disentangling it. This is particularly so within a collective memory constellation: once we have ‘seen’ from this different perspective, we can’t go back to not seeing. It isn’t possible. On some level our awareness of the stories, told and untold, has changed.
Collective memory constellations can be hard to step into and work through because so often the group is leaning into a story or experience that has been rendered voiceless. The act of constellating in the collective Field is an offering of sacred witnessing, to sit with what hasn’t been grieved or told, without the expectation that it will shift to a point of balance and peace. Many times it won’t. The healing comes from the witnessing, the breaking of silences and the sacred acknowledgement that what has happened is worthy of grief. It creates a place for grief of what hasn’t been grieved. We chip away and begin to break those silent vows and inherited beliefs each time we lean into a collective story and immerse ourselves in the telling, feeling, seeing, breaking of the silences, and the grieving.
In the group, the representatives for ‘descendants in the present’ in this particular constellation were weeping and holding the ancestors’ grief within themselves. However, they too could not see the children. The children in the constellation were still unseen and feeling very unsafe. And that is a very important point. The descendants in the present couldn’t see the children. This means that parts of us in the present day cannot see the children. And if we cannot see the children in the collective memories, then that affects us ‘seeing’ the children and the innocent in our present whose stories are resonant with this untold story. The children and innocent in our present become voiceless too. It is a collective entanglement that we are each living with today.
The ‘descendants in the present’ were overwhelmed with the cost of the impossible choices that were made. It was incredibly heavy with the weight of the ungrieved grief.
The ‘descendants in the present’ spoke to the ancestors:
I’m lost.
I don’t know what to do.
I don’t know who to be for you.
I’m lost.
I have to be here because you left.
This narrative shows how entangled the belonging of the descendants is with the unacknowledged grief. We are still living this.
At this point a representative for ‘betrayal’ moved towards the father who had left Ireland. The ‘descendants in the present’ and the Irish ancestors who were still standing within the constellation Field spoke to him:
I am still waiting.
You have forgotten your children.
However, this was all spoken without actually looking at or witnessing the children. No one was looking at them. The grief was immense but untouchable. There was a sense of safety for the ‘descendants in the present’ in placing blame and judgement on what had happened rather than ‘seeing’ the impossible choices and the children. This is incredibly important because when we choose judgement and blame rather than sitting with compassion, then the children are still not seen, and the grief remains ungrieved. The entanglement flows forward from us to the next generations.
There was some movement within the Field from the Irish ancestors who began to see the unacknowledged dead and were able to say:
I see you.
It was at this point, the acknowledgement of the dead, that the children became more withdrawn and spoke:
You’ve forgotten me.
You’ve forgotten me.
Challenging and heartbreaking as it was, it was a powerful act of witnessing and breaking of the silence for the group as they exited the constellation map. For the group, they had been immersed in the ‘not seeing’ and were able to recognise it as an entanglement as well as the cost of the entanglement, past and present.
The grief and guilt of surviving
This entanglement, relating to the ‘not seeing’ of children, appeared again in an online group looking at the collective memories and untold stories of the Irish famine. Our focus this time was the plight of one family in particular, and the influence of their experience on the descendants in the present. In 1847 the children in the family were left at a workhouse in Cork. The mother had died from a fever and the father pretended that the children were orphans. He emigrated to the USA in the hope of eventually being able to come back for the children. But he never did. This story is not unique and was a common occurrence at the time, echoing the earlier example from the previous group constellation of the children not being seen and the father unable to see them.
The dominant entanglement within the created constellation was the grief of the mother not being able to keep her children safe and yet she couldn’t grieve. She was trapped with the weight of the shame and wasn’t able to either see her children or grieve the trauma. The descendants in the present were holding the grief and pain with her.
There was a shift in the holding of the grief for the mothers and the children when the descendants in the present were able to say:
I see you.
This wasn’t your fault.
They took everything from you.
And then they blamed you.
This wasn’t your fault.
I honour your unlived years.
I honour your unlived dreams.
Your love still has a place.
I decided to explore this collective memory further in a longer group session. We met online, which is so valuable for this work, to be able to bring together descendants in the present who are connected with a similar ancestral root but located in the present time in different lands. The group gathered from Ireland, Scotland, England, USA, Africa and France.
The events that ran through the collective experience of the famine can be encapsulated by: evictions, workhouses, disease, migration, coffin ships, death, and of course hunger. The word ‘eviction’ was not commonly used in Irish everyday language at that time, but it soon became commonplace. Some landlords began to take advantage of the unfolding tragedy to clear their land of unwanted tenants.
From 1846 when families had neither food nor money to pay their rents, bailiffs and police were utilised by the landlords to oversee the eviction of their tenants:
“The people were all turned out of doors and the roof of their houses pulled down. That night they made a tent or shelter, of wood and straw, but however the drivers [bailiffs] threw them down and drove them from the place… It would have pitied the sun to look at them, as they had to go head first into the storm… It was a night of high wind and storm, and wailing could be heard at a great distance. They implored the drivers to allow them to remain a short time as it was so near that time of Festival [Christmas] but they would not. Previously 102 families had lived in the area but after the eviction only the walls of three houses remained.” (James Hack Tuke, 1847, cited in Coogan, 2013, p.90)
We stepped into a memory with representatives for: landlords, parents, children, helpers, government, home, hunger, safety, grief, and descendants in the present.
It was again very emotional and once more the fracturing between parents, children, and descendants in the present was illustrated. There was so much grief and pain. The need to keep moving in order to be safe, the need to not know, not feel and to not see was also in evidence. Eventually a healing movement occurred when the descendants in the present broke down in their representation and wept.
“I can see this now. I survived this. I didn’t want to know. I thought it would kill me.”
The weight of the guilt at having come from the survival of this was enormous. Particularly relevant and emotional phrases helped to begin to disentangle the belief that those who survived were living stolen lives. The stories that we come to know when we lean into a collective memory are so important. Not only do we honour and give voice to the voiceless but we are able to identify parts of ourselves that are tangled up in the lost voices and lost souls and what effect it has perhaps on our lives today.
“I am not living a stolen life” is a powerful phrase and it is one I now use regularly in sessions, but why is it so powerful and what does it do? It tackles the silenced shame and humiliation placed upon voiceless victims and it moves the burden of grief and guilt. “My life is not stolen from the dead” allows us to hear and accept, or at least begin to accept that we are each worthy of our lives; that our ancestors were worthy of theirs; that they were worthy of love, belonging, and compassion and so too are we. We bring them home to belonging as we honour their sacred wounds and stories, and we welcome ourselves home to belonging as well.
There is a very real need to grieve the dead, those that didn’t and couldn’t survive; the grief of the fathers that couldn’t provide for their family, the grief of the mothers that couldn’t keep their children safe, and the cost of those that chose to actively perpetrate or to ‘not see’ at the time. It is a deep and complex wound as we will see in our next memory.
Workhouses and Impossible Choices
The next thread of the silenced stories was an exploration of the workhouse memories. The option of going in to a workhouse was held as the last resort for so many souls, and the British government tried to make it as unappealing as possible to actively discourage people from making use of them.
“Every system of poor relief must contain a penal and repulsive element, in order to prevent its leading to the disorganization of society. If the system is such as to be agreeable either to those who relieve or to those who are relieved, and still more if it is agreeable to both, all test of destitution must be at an end.” (Sir Charles Trevelyan to Lord Monteagle, Oct 9, 1846, cited in Coogan, 2013, p.117)
Families were separated upon entering the workhouses. Men, women and children were kept in different areas and were not allowed to mix. It was avoided as an option if possible, but as the Famine and the disease and pain that it brought with it continued to ravage Ireland, souls would often submit to the workhouse or leave a family member there when they were close to death in the hope that they would be afforded a proper coffin burial. The weight of such unrelenting grief and trauma is incomprehensible but the basic need to survive would also kick in. It was common for children to be left at a workhouse by an adult who claimed that the children were orphans when in fact they themselves were the parent. They would leave the children and then board one of the ‘coffin ships’ to the UK or more commonly the USA and Canada. By that time the British government wanted the untenanted land and it was cheaper to pay for ships passage than a place at the workhouse.
So the children were left behind, waiting for the parents to return. And they didn’t. This is the fracturing that we have seen in our memory constellations and why it is so incredibly hard to look to the children from the perspective of both the ancestors and the descendants in the present.
“In passing, along the roads; in going from one town to another, it was quite afflicting to see the state of the children – they were nearly naked, with a few rags upon them; their hair standing on end from poverty; their eyes sunken; their lips pallid, and nothing but the protruding bones of their little joints visible. I could not help exclaiming as I passed them, ‘Am I living in a civilized country and part of the British Empire’?” (Mr. O’Shaughnessy to the Poor Law Committee, June 6, 1849, cited in Coogan, 2013, p.121)
The children didn’t survive for long in the conditions of the workhouse and those that did lived an institutionalised life.
“It was common practice for parents going in search of employment to get their children admitted to the workhouse as orphans… The close whispering lest the conversation should betray them, the sobs and tears when parting, show them to be in a closer degree of relationship. Often this was the last meeting in this world; for the children then went out of life like bubbles bursting on the stream.” (Dr. R. Stephens, 1847, cited in Coogan, 2013, p.133)
The legacy of this inability to protect the children and the abandonment of children is vast, for everyone, past and present – the cost to the children. The cost to the parents. The cost to those who staffed the workhouses. Those who persecuted. The cost of surviving, migrating to another country and trying not to see, to not feel, not remember, to not know.
The weight of that ungrieved grief is immense. And it has festered through the generations of all who are touched by this: the migrant population in the USA and Canada and their descendants, along with those who survived in Ireland and the UK, those who perpetrated or who chose not to see at the time, the children then and the children now.
A place for grief and a place for life
The memory exploration in this topic is a tender one. The weight of the shame is omnipresent. Beliefs running through the generations are that we are not worthy of our place, that we are living stolen lives, that it isn’t safe to be a mother or a father, that the children need to die first in order to keep them safe.
That particular belief of the children needing to die first is a peculiar one and I didn’t understand it at first when I began to see it. It has shown up repeatedly in the background of individual sessions over the last couple of years. Deeply wounded ancestral beliefs are being stirred as part of our collective unfolding of the field of trauma from the Covid-19 pandemic.
One client in particular, Esther, was experiencing extreme anxiety and fear in her every day. She lived in Canada with her partner Bill; both of their family lines could be traced back to Ireland and migration from Ireland during the Famine period. She was paralysed with fear that they would lose their home and their safety because of the pandemic; that there wouldn’t be enough and that they simply wouldn’t survive.
We started off the session by gently bringing in a sense of the land in both Canada and Ireland and having her say aloud:
I am Esther.
I belong.
I belong as a free soul.
I belong as a free woman.
At this point she experienced an overwhelming sense of grief towards the land in Ireland and I asked her to bring in an image of her ancestors left behind there and to say:
I am still remembering.
I am remembering more than the death.
I am remembering more than the suffering.
She struggled at first; she felt a deep sense of shame at being alive in those initial moments. I asked her to bring in images and a sense of her ancestors before the Famine period.
I am remembering the love.
I am remembering the belonging.
I am remembering the innocence.
I am remembering the hope.
I am coming home to that remembering.
I am coming home to myself.
I am Esther and I am a free Irish woman.
I feel you here on this land/soil.
I feel you within my heart.
I don’t have to choose between the lands.
I haven’t forgotten you as I stand on this land.
This is important. Think of the choices that were made by those souls to leave. Think of your own family and what had to be left behind, who had to be left behind and the yearning that exists within those fractures. Those are some of our most poignant voiceless stories, the ghosts of our past. The courage and the devastation. It is easy to accept the single story of ‘We used to be farmers’ or ‘He came over on the boat’ or ‘She went into service in the big house and never went back home’. However, the stories are so much more than that.
Esther became very aware of Bill at this point; I asked her to bring him in and say to him about Ireland and his ancestors:
I feel you here on this land.
I feel where your story weaves with mine.
I am choosing to remember it.
I feel the belief that the children had to die first.
I feel it on that land (Ireland).
I felt it within my parents and family.
I recognise it within your family.
Bill had lived that emotional abandonment from his parents. Any hint of weakness or sickness and they withdrew rather than nourished. They were constantly preparing to lose their children. And this is an entanglement that runs through so many of our untold and voiceless stories of trauma relating to scarcity and ‘not enough’.
I feel you struggling with that belief.
I know that belief well.
For some of our ancestors there was love behind that belief.
It was an impossible choice.
It fractured their souls.
Not all who hold that belief hold it through love.
My parents don’t. Your family don’t.
They were wrong.
It isn’t true.
It wasn’t true then.
It isn’t true now.
You lived.
That is not a betrayal.
I am celebrating your survival.
I am celebrating your recovery.
I am celebrating your health.
I am celebrating your life.
I am celebrating our love.
I chose you – I still choose you.
You chose me – You still choose me.
That is not a betrayal.
NOTES:
These observations are from a series of different in-person and online group constellation sessions from 2019-present. The 2019 group constellation was funded by the Human Family Unity Foundation and was in collaboration with social justice activist Chris Halas Wood in Madison, WI.
The online constellations were part of my monthly Collective Memory online class series.
REFERENCES
Coogan, T.P. (2013) The Famine Plot: England’s Role in Ireland’s Greatest Tragedy. Palgrave Macmillan. London, UK.
Fierke, K., & Mackay, N. (2020) To ‘see’ is to break an entanglement: Quantum Measurement, Trauma and Security. Security Dialogue. Ottawa, Canada.
Kearns, G (2018) Ireland’s Brexit Problem. The AAG Review of Books, Washington DC, USA.
Kenny, K. (2019) Two Diasporic Moments in Irish Emigration History: The Famine Generation and the Contemporary Era. Studi Irlandesi. A Journal of Irish Studies, 9(9), 43-65. Florence, Italy.
Mackay, N. (2020) Your Invisible Inheritance. Rebel Magic Books. England, UK.
Mulvihill, J. (2018) The Truth Behind the Irish Famine 1845-1852. Slick Fish Design. Kerry, Ireland.