Disentangling the Roots of Racism
|
Getting your Trinity Audio player ready...
|
I am a Family Constellation therapist, teacher, and physicist.
I have worked with constellations as a therapeutic modality for nearly two decades. In more recent times, the emphasis of my work has shifted considerably from an individual focus to that of the collective. I have been applying the disentangling tools from constellations within political and collective conflict resolution, through research with a Scottish University, as well as working on roots of racism in the USA.
Looking Beyond
The initial research emphasis was on traumatic entanglements with the past as they relate to political, rather than individual, memory and exploring the hypothesis that collective memories of trauma are an entangled phenomenon that can be triggered by political changes which can bring past traumas to the surface. These entanglements with the past add to the toxicity of current conflict situations, which can be experienced by the present generation through the inherited memory of the suffering, forced displacement and violence experienced by the previous generations. This is apparent both individually, and collectively.
Those who occupy positions within a relational system, such as a constellation, are able to represent the bodily sensations, feelings and impulses of someone whom they do not know. In our experiment these were associated with categories of memory that are larger than the individual; thus they will express the collective experience of suffering in the past that is being re-experienced in the present.
In exploring the notion that trauma represents an entanglement with the past, the project sought to explore the quantum notion that to ‘see’ an entanglement is to break it.
In the course of the research, we had undertaken a particular constellation to try to understand why racism and slavery were not being ‘seen’ in the USA within the exploratory research constellations. I ended a constellation exploring the invisibility of racism and slavery at an intractable point that I found deeply disturbing. It is important to note here that the constellations in the study were conducted blind, meaning that neither I nor the representatives knew what they were representing. This was to ensure that any personal bias would not influence how the constellation transpired.
Within the constellation, the representatives for ‘white working class men’ and the ‘US government system’ were found to be behaving callously towards a representative for slavery.
The representative of slavery was unable to stand within the created constellation field – the weight of the trauma being so great. They were weeping and on their knees, clearly in considerable pain. And the other representatives were laughing – quite gleefully. It was chilling to witness such overt perpetration energy within a constellation and for it to be so intractable. There was a complete absence of any compassionate response. Instead there was overt hate and perpetration.
I shared this with a colleague and the sharing happened to coincide with their own exploration of the roots of racism within the USA through their social justice and activism work. We decided to explore this further and began to work with constellations as a tool to uncover the roots of racism. I would like to be able to say that I haven’t seen such a visceral hate response in a constellation since that day, but I can’t. I have witnessed it repeatedly when focusing on this subject.
Constellation Work is a systemic tool that allows access to the hidden stories and the silenced voices of the previous generations within the historical narrative. It is all too easy to accept a version of events that is passed down from one generation to the next, from one person to the next, but with each telling, the story can become that little bit more sanitised, a little more palatable or diluted for each generation.
A story is generally told from one perspective and that perspective may not be the complete story; it may be skewed. When we share or tell stories from a collective narrative we can shape how events are remembered.
Take a world-changing event like WWI. It would be impossible to give a complete and accurate representation of such a massive collective event. Instead it is remembered through individual re-telling. The collective narrative is thus comprised of a collection of memories drawn from a massive tangle of individual experiences and stories. But what of the individual stories contained within? Where are the separated lovers, the grieving mothers, the orphans, the dead? Their untold stories are the ones that tug at the edges of consciousness within the individual family and ancestral fields. Those are the silent voices that come forward when we explore a collective theme within the constellation context. The collective constellations are where the root entanglements of fear come from for each of us individually.
The Fracturing of Forced Displacement
Migration of some kind within a family historical narrative, whether through choice or otherwise, is not uncommon. If there is unresolved trauma around the migration, the entanglement will be rooted to that time, with those ancestors, and this will flow down the line to the present generation. It also flows from the belonging of a particular land or country to the civilians that knowingly or unknowingly belong to that land or country.
This belonging can be in the present or past. Several generations may pass with the family or a particular branch of the family being established in the new land. However the first loyalty, known or unknown, will be to the land of origin and to those left behind. The land of origin within the ancestral line has greater influence upon the individual in question, particularly if there is an entanglement around land, be it displacement, enslavement, perpetration, betrayal, exclusion or belief associated.
In exploring these influences within conflict-focused constellations, there is a triangulation that repeatedly appears. It is the entangled connection between ‘those left behind’, ‘those who left’ and the ‘descendants in the present’. This triangulation is critical to disentangling enslavement trauma.
In each and every constellation that I have observed, the most animated and influential represented space was ‘those left behind’.
An historical narrative of migration within the individual and family context cannot be ignored. It is this very triangulation that is the root cause of entanglements around a lack of compassionate response or a sacrificing response to the current geo-political changes.
In part of the group work, looking at the normalisation of hate and the roots of racism within the US, the dislocated memories of a collective memory were explored. The US based group work was a mix of blind and non-blind constellations. The intention was to explore further the blocks to ‘seeing’ the trauma associated with slavery after several blind constellations had shown it to be ‘invisible’ within the structure of the current political system.
In each of the preceding constellations the trauma within the roots of slavery was compartmentalised and unseen. Within the created Constellation Field, the dominance was given to the ‘white’ trauma instead. Because of this emergent theme, we decided to set the intention to look through the lens of the unacknowledged trauma within African American families who had been enslaved in our next focus group. We intentionally kept the focus there, to avoid the obfuscating presence of the narrative of white guilt.
Four historical true-life accounts of individuals who had been enslaved were explored. It was highly emotive. There was deep wounding between the generations of the ancestors themselves with mothers and children being torn apart. The parents’ relationship promises and the place of the children were deeply entangled with the trauma of grief, persecution, loss and fear.
An example of this is the initial movements within a constellation between an enslaved woman ‘Mary’, the descendants of Mary in the present, the plantation owner and their descendants.
Mary had been repeatedly raped by the plantation owner and the resulting children were then sold. Mary, her children, and the descendants in the present were slowly drawn to one another within the created Field and there was a significant and highly emotive guilt response from the descendants towards Mary. The movement and connection were strengthened with the spoken narrative from the descendants, to Mary:
“I see you.”
“I come from you.”
“My blood is your blood.”
This softened the field of influence within the entire constellation. There was a further movement and relaxation with the introduction of Mary’s husband to the constellation space. When Mary’s husband took his place and looked at and connected with the descendants of Mary that were a product of rape, there was further relaxation within the representation of the descendants.
The love between Mary and her husband had a place and the descendants could see, honour, and accept that too. There was more than rape and perpetration within the line. This was solidified with the spoken narrative to Mary from her husband:
“You are still my wife and I am still your husband. Our love still has a place.”
This movement of seeing and accepting the place of love shifted the silently held shame and guilt within the field of influence upon Mary’s descendants.
The belonging remained entangled with the plantation owner’s family field and the displaced trauma was invisibly inherited down the generational line for both the descendants of the enslaved and those who had enslaved.
Aside from the clear and obvious fracturing of the field, there was a striking and alarming emergent theme. Regardless of how much was revealed, acknowledged and healed within the historical trauma narrative of those who had been enslaved, there was a distinct block to any real movement around belonging.
In each of the four constellations the belonging of those individuals who had been enslaved was deeply entangled with the belonging of those who had enslaved them. This was reflected not only with the historical account but also the descendants of both enslaved and enslaver within present generations.
They were not necessarily tied to the individuals who enslaved them, but to the enslavers’ entangled belonging. The enslaved and descendants of the enslaved were entangled with the unacknowledged trauma around the fracturing of the enslavers’ own families and those left behind within their field of influence – the unseen trauma of the cost of the ancestors who moved to the USA and the ancestors who were left behind in Europe. The belonging in the USA for those who enslaved, and the systemic hierarchy of belonging that comes through enslavement, appears to be built on an unconscious belief that it is safer ‘not to see’.
The descendants of enslavers in the present were very active within each of the constellations and this is a theme that has continued throughout each of the focus group explorations. However, there was a desperation in the witnessing on behalf of the descendants of the enslavers and this was not an altruistic movement.
The descendants of the enslavers were entangled within the unacknowledged guilt associated with the unseen and unacknowledged dead and there is a cost to this witnessing. They are essentially asking to be released and absolved from the weight of the historical guilt by those who were enslaved as a result of the original trauma. They are not looking to the unacknowledged dead themselves; they are repeatedly asking those who were enslaved to do it on their behalf. In essence saying “Forgive me. Look for me.” rather than “I see you. I see them. I witness the pain and the cost.”
This piece did not move and was also presented as a root of hate.
Throughout each of the focus groups and the constellations that formed them, there was a recurring unwillingness within those who enslaved to look at the cost of that trauma, or to give place to it. There was the presence of an unconscious belief that the hate was safer than a compassionate response, because a compassionate response would open up the pain from the past and threaten belonging. And this belief, this choice, is held by the ancestors and the descendants in the present.
What was very noticeable in the analysis of the constellations was the lack of impact of the presence of the dead within the created Constellation Field. They were simply not seen. There was no place for grief. The weight and compartmentalisation of the guilt at the beginning of the constellations remained throughout.
There continued to be resistance to seeing and connecting with the dead and the victims, and the constellations switched back and forth through the victim and perpetrator responses looking for safety and belonging.
There was a lack of depth to the movements – despite their great significance within the context of the constellation – because of the unacknowledged root trauma and the cost of belonging for ‘those who enslaved’. The most poignant and significant moment of healing within the entire constellation occurred with the reconnection of John, a man who had been lynched, to his family and descendants. Despite this healing movement and reconnection there was no similar healing shift with the ‘descendants of the perpetrators’, or ‘those who enslaved’ with their ancestors.
The Field was blocked by the root entanglements that repeatedly appear to be related to the cost of belonging to the land in the USA, and the beliefs therein. This inability to acknowledge the dead and the weight of the trauma within the lineage of belonging of the enslavers, again, held the victims, or enslaved, in a space of belonging through the persecutors or enslavers.
Until this and the associated dead within the unacknowledged trauma are witnessed and acknowledged then the forward movement and healing will continue to be limited. And there will be no space for a compassionate response.
The observed entanglements are a representation of the non-acknowledgement of the cost of enslavement and racism. It is held as a belief, and holds a narrative of persecution of belief, that comes from the land of origin of the enslavers.
If enslavement ends and the enslaved souls are no longer ‘owned’, then nothing stands in the way of the enslavers’ own unacknowledged guilt and trauma. Not only are the enslaved not free, with the heavy burden that comes from that alone, they are also entangled with and burdened by the historical guilt of those that have enslaved them. This is part of the resistance, unconscious or otherwise, to the end of enslavement that exists to this day.
I have observed this fracture of the deep entanglement of ‘those left behind’, ‘those who left’ and ‘descendants in the present’ repeatedly throughout individual and collective, focused constellations.
There is significant value in experiencing the effect of systemic racism in this way as a white representative – to choose to be present and to contribute to healing … The choices we make now can make a difference and they do matter.
Exploring the unacknowledged trauma within the historical narrative of the white migrant community and the fear of seeing the dead and the cost of leaving their countries of origin, appears to be part of the informing root of white supremacy culture and the racialisation of whiteness as superior. The root of that comes from the unacknowledged and deep fracturing trauma that is overlaid with the migration triangulation and the guilt of surviving.
In attempting to explore the unseen and unacknowledged trauma potentially impacting the ability of individuals in the present to ‘see’ enslavement and racism work, I began to explore the possible collective traumatic memories from historical European migration to the USA. An example of one of the influential historical collective memories that I am currently exploring relates to the Irish famine in the 19th century and the resulting mass migration to the USA and elsewhere. This work is still in progress as is the formal research project.
Exploring the unacknowledged guilt and shame entangled with migration and forced displacement is so relevant for unpacking the layers of trauma influencing present-day experiences.
The visceral hate and perpetration that appears within constellations exploring racism and enslavement is disturbing. However, it is showing what is actually there within the field of influence. It is a lived experience for communities, and people of colour everyday. An aspect of white culture is that people who are white don’t have to ‘see’ or ‘feel’ this in their everyday lives. This is a privilege. There is significant value in experiencing the effect of systemic racism in this way as a white representative – to choose to be present and to contribute to healing.
The choices we make now can make a difference and they do matter.
When we choose to see the ‘unseen’ within the historical narrative of trauma it can become a radical act that provokes a shift into an unentangled state for our ancestors, ourselves and, ultimately, our descendants.
NOTES:
These observations are from two separate projects in two different countries. The research project is a collaboration with Prof. K.M. Fierke at St. Andrews University. The focus, constellations exploring the roots of racism, is an ongoing series of public workshops in collaboration with social justice activist Chris Halas Wood in Madison, WI. I am deeply grateful to work with each of them.
REFERENCES
Boring, F. M. (2012) Connecting to Our Ancestral Past. North Atlantic Books, Berkeley, CA, USA.
Diangelo, R. (2018) White Fragility: Why It’s So Hard for White People to Talk About Racism. Penguin. https://www.penguin.com.au/books/white-fragility-9780141990569 Reprint by Penguin Publishing – 2019 Penguin, Australia. 2018 publication Beacon Press, Boston, USA.
Eddo-Lodge, R. (2018) Why I’m No Longer Talking to White People About Race. Bloomsbury Publishing, London WC1, England, UK.
Fierke, K., & Mackay, N. (2020) To ‘see’ is to break an entanglement: Quantum Measurement, Trauma and Security. Security Dialogue. Sage Publications on behalf of the Peace Research Institute, Oslo, Norway.
Menakem, R. (2017) My Grandmother’s Hands: Racialized Trauma and the Pathway to Mending Our Hearts and Bodies. Central Recovery Press, Las Vegas, Nevada, USA.
Mackay, N. (2009) The Science of Family: Working with Ancestral Patterns. O Books, England, UK.
Mackay, N. (2012) Between the Lines: Healing the Individual & Ancestral Soul with Family Constellation. O. Books, England, UK.
Mackay, N (2020) Your Invisible Inheritance. Rebel Magic Books, England, UK.
Shivanath, S. H. (2003) The psycho-dynamics of race and culture. In H. S. Hargaden, Ego states (Key concepts in transactional analysis: Contemporary views) (pp. 169–185). Worth Publishing, London, UK.